PM: We don't need poverty line to help the poor

Singapore's needy have diverse needs that call for multi-layered help

By Rachel Chang, The Sunday Times, 17 Nov 2013

Singapore is past the point where a poverty line is useful, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong indicated yesterday, as its groups of needy now take shifting and multi-faceted form.

Hence, the Government's "kueh lapis" approach to social assistance, he said, summoning a metaphor that Minister of Social and Family Development Chan Chun Sing used to describe the multi-layered help it provides to those in need.

Speaking to reporters after a Commonwealth summit in Sri Lanka, Mr Lee weighed in for the first time on recent calls to establish a poverty line in Singapore, after Hong Kong did so in September.

He said that a poverty line like the World Bank's measure of $1.50 a day was irrelevant in Singapore as there are no "dead poor" here, by which he means those who are starving and unsheltered.

Rather, the poor here range from those going through temporary setbacks to families suddenly felled by illness, to the needy elderly and low-skilled workers.

Each of these groups needs a different sort and scale of help, and often, "men and women of good sense" are required to assess what assistance is desirable and necessary in each case.

This cannot be accomplished by a rigid poverty line, he said, which might be polarising and leave some outside the definition of poor.

"To say as an ideological matter that 'I must have a proper definition, and I want to reduce this group to zero' - I think we have moved beyond that point and I don't think that a definition will help us to improve our schemes," he said.

Mr Lee also dismissed suggestions that a poverty line would help "focus minds" on the issue of the poor in Singapore.

"What is important to us is not about whether we can find a definition with which we can focus minds on the problem, because our minds are focused on the problem," he said.

There are many people doing social work of various kinds in Singapore, he added, a diversity of effort that could actually be hindered by the establishment of an all-encompassing poverty line.

The topic dovetailed with discussions at the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, whose theme was "Growth with Equity".

During retreat sessions with leaders of the 53-member grouping, PM Lee set out Singapore's approach to sustainable development, explaining why it is careful to spend within its means and not provide a false sense of well-being through deficit spending.

While it is right for governments to shield their people from the uncertainties and inequalities of the globalised world, it is hard to translate "noble intentions" and social spending into real gains, he said.

In some countries, heavy public spending has not solved the problems of unemployment and a lack of competitiveness but has led to growing debt, he said.

Singapore's approach is to live within its means so as not to leave the next generation indebted, pursue long-term growth strategies rather than deficit spending, and protect the environment, he summed up.

Later, he told reporters that the biennial Commonwealth meet remained a valuable point of contact between Singapore and countries in Africa and the Caribbean that it did not have many direct links with.

On the sidelines of the two-day summit, PM Lee met his counterparts from Malta, Rwanda, Tanzania and Vanuatu for bilateral discussions.

He also congratulated Sri Lankan president Mahinda Rajapaksa on a summit well-hosted.

Economic growth must benefit wide segment of society: PM Lee
By Imelda Saad, Channel NewsAsia, 16 Nov 2013

Economic growth must benefit a wide segment of society, or else political consensus to support growth will fail, said Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

He made the point on Saturday at the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in Colombo, Sri Lanka.

This year's meeting centres on the theme of inclusive development, namely “Growth With Equity: Inclusive Development”.

Speaking to leaders, Prime Minister Lee said for equitable growth to take place, it is crucial for countries to maintain a healthy and growing economy.

But he stressed that prosperity must result in better lives, jobs, living conditions and opportunities for all.

He noted how globalisation has led to growing anxiety among the low-income and middle-income groups.

Mr Lee said governments cannot reverse these trends, but it must mitigate downsides and shield people from uncertainties and inequalities. The challenge, he said, is to do it well.

In some ways, the 53 member countries of the Commonwealth reflect the growing income disparity governments are facing in their own countries.

Commonwealth members are made up of some of the world's richest and poorest states, spanning across Asia, Africa and the Pacific.

One of the approaches to address the problem of inequity is state welfare and observers have pointed out that this does not necessarily work.

Mr Lee said that with state welfare, it is hard to translate noble intentions and social spending into real gains.

Heavy public spending, he said, has often not solved problems of unemployment and lack of competitiveness. Instead, it results in fiscal deficits and growing debt.

One way out of this, said Mr Lee, is to pursue sustainable development -- which means, governments living within its means and pursuing development strategies that sustain growth over the long term.

Mr Lee said: "We need to live within our means, collectively, so we do not indebt our children. Pursue development strategies that sustain sound growth over the long-term, and not a transient, false sense of well-being through deficit spending, asset bubbles, or depleting natural resources."

He said Singapore has tried to adhere to these development principles and it has shared its experiences through the Commonwealth Third Country Training Programme, Singapore Cooperation Programme.

More than 100,000 officials from over 170 countries have been trained under the initiative -- including 20,000 Commonwealth officials -- in matters such as public governance, information technology and trade facilitation.


Related
Tackling poverty the 'kuih lapis' way
Assistance schemes for needy
Debunking the welfare myth